Two Palm Valley lots now holding mobile homes could become offices and car condos. County planners review both Thursday, and commissioners vote Dec. 15.

Two lots in Palm Valley that now hold mobile homes could become an office park and a block of private car condos. The St. Johns County Planning and Zoning Agency reviews both rezonings at 1:30 p.m. Thursday at the County Auditorium, 500 San Sebastian View, St. Augustine. The agency’s Nov. 19 agenda lists them as items 6 and 7.

The agency only recommends. The Board of County Commissioners is scheduled to decide both on Tuesday, Dec. 15, according to the county staff reports. Both sites are in District 4, Commissioner Krista Joseph’s district, and both are in the Palm Valley Overlay District.

Overview

5165 Palm Valley Road 300 North Roscoe Boulevard
Size 1.79 acres 2.5 acres
On the site now A mobile home A mobile home
Proposed Up to 16,200 square feet of professional and medical offices A 3,000-square-foot office and two 9,000-square-foot garage buildings
Buildings Three, up to 20 feet tall Three, up to 25 feet tall
Waivers asked Four Four
Letters to the county Neighbors opposed at first, then reached an agreement None received

Palm Valley Landing Professional Center

The larger office plan is on the east side of Palm Valley Road, about 0.65 miles south of State Road A1A. The owner is listed as PVB Amelia Group LLC. The staff report says the site holds a mobile home built in 1978.

The plan allows professional and medical offices only. Its written terms rule out retail, restaurants, storage, private clubs, outpatient surgery, vape shops and massage businesses. The Woodlands neighborhood borders the land on two sides. The Ponte Vedra Gardens assisted living center is next door to the south.

The traffic figures are the part most drivers will notice:

  • The stretch of Palm Valley Road from Canal Boulevard to A1A already runs at 102.7% of its capacity at the evening peak, based on 2025 counts.
  • Counting traffic from projects already approved, it reaches 111.3%.
  • All medical offices would add an estimated 583 trips a weekday, 54 of them between 4 and 6 p.m.
  • All general offices would add an estimated 308 trips a weekday, 47 of them at the evening peak.

Office projects are exempt from the county’s road capacity rules, the report says, so the developer pays road impact fees instead. County staff told the applicant a right-turn lane will be needed. An all-medical building would need left- and right-turn lanes.

The site has 0.73 acres of wetlands, and the plan fills all of them. The applicant also asks to skip the rule that keeps 5% of upland vegetation, saying the site has to be raised to match its neighbors. The plan sets aside a 17-foot strip along the front for future widening of Palm Valley Road.

Neighbors directly to the east first wrote to the county opposing the plan, raising screening, landscaping and drainage. The applicant has since agreed on a screening plan with them, the report says. It includes an 8-foot vinyl privacy fence and a row of evergreen trees along that side. Staff did not object to any of the four waivers.

Car condos on North Roscoe Boulevard

The second site is on the east side of North Roscoe Boulevard, about 0.15 miles south of Solana Road. The staff report describes two six-bay garage buildings to be sold as private car condos. They would be gated and open to their owners around the clock. A one-story office would face the road, and the lot would also carry parking for nearby businesses.

The county estimates the office would add 43 trips a weekday and the garages 23. That stretch of Roscoe Boulevard, from Canal Boulevard to PGA Tour Boulevard, runs at 65.7% of capacity.

The four waivers would:

  • cut the side setback on the south edge from 50 feet to 10 feet, next to the Beth El The Beach synagogue
  • use planted buffers in place of an 8-foot masonry wall
  • swap the overlay district’s heavier roadside landscaping for the county’s standard buffer
  • allow a nearly flat 1/12 roof pitch on the garages, where the overlay requires at least 5/12

Staff found the setback cut “reasonable” and the buffers sufficient. On the roof, the report says the lower pitch keeps the buildings shorter next to the synagogue, but is “substantially less than the minimum slope established by the Code.” The Ponte Vedra/Palm Valley Architectural Review Committee reviewed the plan in an Oct. 28 workshop and “expressed support for the proposed use and site layout,” the report says. Staff had received no letters or calls about it.

Also next week: Inn & Club racquet courts

The Ponte Vedra/Palm Valley Architectural Review Committee meets at 5 p.m. Wednesday at the Ponte Vedra Beach Branch Library, 101 Library Blvd. Its Nov. 18 agenda includes design changes to the Racquet Club at PVIC, 280 Ponte Vedra Blvd. The request would reduce the number of pickleball courts and add two padel courts. It also changes the shade structures’ colors, adds a maintenance shed and revises the landscaping. County staff recommend approval, according to the staff report. The agenda does not say how many pickleball courts would remain.

What it means for you

  • To speak on the rezonings, attend the Planning and Zoning Agency at 1:30 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 19, or the commission meeting Dec. 15. Both are quasi-judicial hearings. The county attorney’s note in each report says the boards weigh specific, fact-based evidence, not the number of people in a petition.
  • To write in, contact the planner named on each report: Trevor Steven at 904-209-0587 for Palm Valley Road, and Abrielle Genest at 904-209-0598 for North Roscoe. Letters become part of the record.
  • If you drive Palm Valley Road at rush hour, the county’s own figures say that stretch is already past capacity before either project is built.